Learning Center

We keep you up-to-date on the latest tax changes and news in the industry.

Bootlegging Revived: Indiana's New Cigarette Tax Era

As Indiana implements a significant hike in its cigarette taxes, it invokes the spirit of the prohibition era, rejuvenating both tax policy and illegal sales prevention efforts. The increase, as detailed here, is more than just a monetary adjustment; it's a nuanced battle against smuggling, reminiscent of historical operations against bootleg beer and tobacco rings of the 1930s.

Image 1

Kentucky, boasting one of the lowest cigarette taxes in the region, remains a hotbed for cross-border sales. This has positioned it alongside Tennessee, which experienced a surge in bootlegging after raising its tax rates, as a case study in interstate smuggling. For further details, see this analysis.

Data from a 2018 study further underscores this point, illustrating how states, including Indiana, have managed to boost revenues despite increased rates of smuggling.

New Enforcement Measures

To counteract these potential setbacks, Indiana has enacted stringent laws aimed at curbing illicit trade:

  • Outlawing bulk out-of-state purchases: New felony charges await those caught tampering with tax codes by purchasing in volume across state borders.

  • Enhanced surveillance efforts: Broadened partnerships between Excise and state police now oversee crucial points like toll booths and warehouse hubs.

  • Surprise audits: These audits target wholesalers and retailers, ensuring adherence to tax stamp legitimacy.

  • Revenue projection of $290 million: Expected funds are earmarked for pivotal public health initiatives.

Image 2

Pervasive Temptations Beyond State Borders

Given Indiana’s adjacency to low-tax states, this tax hike might inadvertently encourage illegal distribution. A report on tax foundation elucidates this threat, indicating the state's high potential for smuggling spike induced by tax increments.

Complicating matters, Ohio—with its low cigarette tax—offers bargain pricing just a short drive away, making it a preferred alternative for Hoosier smokers.

Lessons From Illinois and New York

Illinois: Facing similar challenges, Illinois has responded with a significant nicotine tax and steep penalties for illegal shipments, detailed here. Despite state efforts, roughly 30% of cigarettes are believed to be illegally procured across borders.

New York: Enacting one of the nation’s highest taxes has driven smuggling rates up to 61%. Strict enforcement by agencies like the Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, & Firearms is ongoing as detailed here.

Image 3

Indiana's Legacy and Future

The state’s storied history in bootlegging—as chronicled here—speaks to the persistent ingenuity in evading regulatory measures, evolving from moonshine to modern-day cigarette trafficking.

However, despite the foreseeable jump in smuggling—projected between 10% to 30%—health advocates insist the higher prices are ultimately a win. Data points from the Indiana Capital Chronicle emphasize the potential to drive down smoking rates.

Indiana risks much on this intricate balance of deterrence and revenue enhancement. The overriding question remains: Can a state steeped in a legacy of evasion finally outpace the modern-day smugglers who now traverse its highways?

Share this article...

Want our best tax and accounting tips and insights delivered to your inbox?

Sign up for our newsletter.

I confirm this is a service inquiry and not an advertising message or solicitation. By clicking “Submit”, I acknowledge and agree to the creation of an account and to the and .
Questions? We have answers.
FAQ
Please fill out the form and our team will get back to you shortly The form was sent successfully